If you plan on traveling during colder months, you may be wondering what the best option is for staying warm. Some RVs may already have more than one option to choose from, because each heating type has its own application, and they are not interchangeable. 

The short answer: a furnace will always be the best primary heat source during the coldest temperatures. Heat strips and heat pumps are best for milder temperatures, taking the chill out of cool mornings and evenings while reducing propane usage. Keep reading to learn more about each of these options: how they work, pros and cons, and how to choose the best setup for your space. 


So, Where Do I Start?

The best place to start is with the outdoor temperature. This is the most important factor in deciding which heat source makes sense. The general guidance is as follows: 

  • Above ~45°F: Heat pumps pull warmth from the outside air and move it indoors rather than creating heat with fuel or a heating element. At these temperatures, there is enough heat in the air for a heat pump to be effective.

  • Below ~45°F: This is the typical cutoff for optimal heat pump performance, because the outside air doesn't provide enough heat to absorb. This is when a heat strip and/or furnace may be needed. 

  • Below freezing: A propane furnace is the only heat source that can stand up to freezing temperatures to provide adequate heating to the entire living space. 


Propane Furnace: Your Primary Heat Source

A propane furnace provides heat by burning LP gas (short for liquefied petroleum gas, the "formal name" for propane) and moving the heated air through the ductwork, or directly into the living space depending on your specific setup. Suburban, the brand we carry, offers several model families for different RV sizes and layouts: 

SF-Q & SF-FQ Series

  • Designed for ducted systems 
  • 20,000 - 40,000 BTU 
  • SF-Q: Requires an exterior access door for installation and service
  • SF-FQ: No exterior access door; service is performed from the interior, and only a small vent terminal on the exterior is needed
  • SF-VHQ & SF-VHFQ models can be mounted vertically or horizontally

NT-SEQ Series

  • Direct discharge: moves heat directly into the living space (also called "non-ducted")
  • 16,000 & 19,000 BTU 
  • Designed for smaller interiors or zone heating ("zone" heating means heating one specific area/room rather than the entire living space)

P-40 Park Model

  • Designed for ducted systems 
  • 40,000 BTU
  • 120V motors and controls; made for stationary applications where the unit stays in place rather than traveling

The lowest BTU rating offered across these units is 16,000 BTU. Keep this in mind when comparing furnaces to heat strips and heat pumps. 

Most Suburban furnaces run on 12VDC power, which allows them to operate without shore power. The P-40 Park Model is the exception. It requires 120V power, which is why it is meant for stationary applications with a permanent power hookup. 

Pros

  • Highest output of all three heating options (by far)
  • Capable of standing up to freezing temperatures
  • Ducted applications: furnaces route heat through the same duct system as the rooftop unit
  • Runs on the propane and 12V power already provided by the RV (except for P-40 Park Models)
  • Wide range of sizing options

Cons

  • It burns propane, which means keeping a closer eye on tank levels
  • Gas appliances should only be serviced or installed by a qualified technician

If you're planning on installing a new furnace, you can view our catalog here. Each furnace description lists required components and compatibility. If you have an existing furnace that isn't performing well, you can find replacement cores (the "guts" of the furnace) here. You can always reach out through our contact page if you have any questions before ordering. We're happy to help!


Heat Pumps: Supplemental Heating

A heat pump is a rooftop air conditioner that can also provide heating. Rather than creating heat through burning fuel or with an electric heating element, it absorbs heat from the outside air and moves it indoors. Because they don't create heat, they aren't meant to be a primary heating source as temperatures drop towards freezing. As the temperature drops, less heat is available to be absorbed. This causes decreased efficiency and, eventually, causes the compressor to shut down while the blower keeps circulating air. The exact cutoff for heat pump usage can vary a bit between manufacturers, but ~45°F is a good rule of thumb for when to switch to the furnace. 

Pros 

  • Effective electric heating in mild cold
  • Built into a rooftop air conditioner rather than being a separate appliance
  • Can reduce propane usage 
  • Some wall thermostats can automatically switch on the furnace when the heat pump cannot keep up

Cons

  • Loses effectiveness in temperatures around the mid 40s
  • Needs 115VAC power; cannot run on a battery alone

Heat Strips: Add-On Electric Heat

A heat strip, sometimes called a "heater assembly," is an add-on electric heating element for rooftop air conditioners. It provides supplemental heating, similar to a heat pump. 

Many rooftop units are heat strip compatible, but it's important to check your other components too. Before you order a heat strip, confirm that the rooftop unit, ceiling assembly, control box, and wall thermostat (if you have one) are all compatible. If you're unsure about your system's compatibility, reach out to us before ordering. 

Pros

  • Simple electric heat for cool mornings and evenings
  • Available options for many existing rooftop units
  • Offer a cheaper, less time consuming option than replacing a rooftop unit or adding a furnace

Cons

  • Only adds 5,000-6,000 BTUs of heating
  • Less effective at colder temperatures
  • May require replacing additional components

Side by Side Comparison

Propane Furnace Heat Pump Heat Strip
Heat Source LP gas (propane) Absorbs heat from outside air Electric heating element
Effective Temperatures Handles sub-freezing temperatures Above ~45°F Above ~45°F
Best Application Primary heating for the entire living space Supplemental heating; Reducing propane usage Gentle warmth in mild temperatures
Consider... More frequent propane refills Decreased efficiency and possible freeze up below a certain temperature Very low output compared to a furnace; may require additional component swaps

Choosing the Best Setup

For many, the best setup is layered, utilizing two or more of these components, each doing its own job: 

  • Heat pump for when temperatures are in the specified operating range
  • Heat strip for a quick warm up or to boost the heat pump's heat output
  • Furnace for colder temperatures or when shore power isn't available

Heat Pump + Furnace

  •  Best for: 
    • Spring & fall seasons
    • Mild winter climates
    • Sites with electric hookups 
  • How heating is divided: 
    • Heat pump: everyday heating on electric hookups
    • Furnace: in reserve, takes over when needed
  • Keep in mind: 
    • Furnace may be needed to protect plumbing, depending on how the ducts are routed

Heat Strip + Furnace

  • Best for: 
    • Mild climates or "in-between" weather
    • Adding supplemental heat to a heat ready rooftop air conditioner
    • Cheapest way to add heating with compatible components
  • How heating is divided: 
    • Heat strip: cool mornings and evenings
    • Furnace: in reserve, takes over when temperatures drop 
  • Keep in mind: 
    • May require swapping other components (wall thermostat, control box, etc)

Heat Pump + Heat Strip + Furnace

  • Best for: 
    • Full-timers
    • Harsher winters
    • Inconsistent electric hookup availability
  • How heating is divided: 
    • Heat pump: mild nights when electric hookups are available
    • Heat strip: quick warmups, can take over when the heat pump needs to defrost
    • Furnace: takes over in colder temperatures or when electric hookups are unavailable
  • Keep in mind: 
    • Not all heat pumps are heat strip compatible

FAQ

Can I heat my RV with just a heat strip?

Only in very mild weather. A heat strip can take the chill out of a spring or autumn morning, but it quickly loses effectiveness as temperatures drop closer to freezing. 

At what temperature does a heat pump stop working well? 

Most rooftop heat pumps are most effective above ~45°. Below that, there isn't enough heat outside for the system to absorb, and a freeze up can shut down the compressor. 

What do I need to add a heat strip to my air conditioner?

All system components must be compatible in order to support a heat strip. Check your rooftop unit, wall thermostat, control box, and ceiling assembly. You may need to replace one or more additional components. 

Can I install an LP furnace myself? 

Furnaces are meant to be installed and serviced only by qualified technicians. Depending on the manufacturer, installing a furnace yourself may void warranties, and can be unsafe if gas-related components are not installed correctly. 

Which heating option is best for protecting tanks and water lines? 

This depends more on how ducting is routed rather than the heat source. A furnace is always the best option for freezing temperatures, but the heat may not be routed in a way that protects against frozen tanks and water lines. 

 

If you have any further questions, you can always reach out to us through our contact page!